Too Good to Be True Cast 2024: Full List of Actors and Characters

If you’ve ever wondered what it’s like when a cleaning single mum catches the attention of a wealthy, mysterious man, then Channel 5’s Too Good to Be True has you hooked. The 2024 psychological thriller stars Kara Tointon as Rachel and Allen Leech as Elliot, and the real surprise? Tointon’s own sister is an actress too, adding a layer of off-screen drama that fans love to explore.

Main cast members: 5 ·
Year of release: 2024 ·
Network: Channel 5 ·
Lead actress: Kara Tointon ·
Lead actor: Allen Leech

Six key facts, one pattern: the series packs a tight thriller into just four episodes.

Where did they film Too Good to Be True?

As a British production for Channel 5, the series was filmed in the United Kingdom. Exact locations have not been officially confirmed, but industry speculation points to Manchester and surrounding areas.

The implication: the UK setting gives the thriller a grounded, atmospheric backdrop that fits the genre’s conventions.

Who is in the cast of Too Good to Be True?

Kara Tointon as Rachel

• Kara Tointon plays Rachel Connor, a single mother working as a cleaner (Radio Times; What to Watch)
• She is best known for her role as Dawn Swann in EastEnders (What to Watch)
• Her other credits include Mr Selfridge, The Halcyon, Father Brown (What to Watch)

Allen Leech as Elliot

• Allen Leech plays Elliot Fielding, a wealthy and mysterious man (Radio Times)
• Leech is widely known for his role as Tom Branson in Downton Abbey (What to Watch)

Charlie Hodson-Prior as Liam

• Charlie Hodson-Prior plays Liam Connor, Rachel’s son (Radio Times)

Sara Powell as Simone

• Sara Powell plays Simone, a businesswoman who connects Rachel with Elliot (Radio Times; Entertainment Daily)
• Powell is known for roles in HolbyBlue, Damned, Silent Witness (Radio Times)

Taj Atwal as Jasmine

• Taj Atwal plays Jasmine (Radio Times)
• Atwal is known for Trying, Line of Duty, Hullraisers (Radio Times)

John Thomson as Geoff

• John Thomson plays Geoff, Rachel’s boss (Radio Times; What to Watch)

Other cast members

• Oliver Devoti plays Keiron (Radio Times)

The pattern: the casting choices anchor the drama in proven talent, making the psychological twists land harder.

Is Kara Tointon Hannah Tointon’s sister?

Yes, Kara Tointon is the sister of actress Hannah Tointon. Both are British actresses, but Hannah Tointon does not appear in Too Good to Be True. This family connection is a frequent search topic among fans.

How many children does Kara Tointon have?

Kara Tointon has one child. She announced her pregnancy in 2021. Her family life occasionally draws public interest alongside her acting career.

What role does Simone play in Too Good to Be True?

Simone is a businesswoman who puts Rachel in touch with the wealthy client Elliot (Entertainment Daily). She is portrayed by Sara Powell, an actress known for her work in British television.

The connection: Simone acts as the catalyst for the thriller’s central relationship, setting the plot in motion.

What is Simone Kirby known for?

Simone Kirby is a different actress, not part of Too Good to Be True. The confusion may arise from the similar first name. Simone Kirby is known for roles in Peaky Blinders and Hinterland, but she does not appear in this series.

For Channel 5 viewers, the choice to cast EastEnders and Downton Abbey alumni ensures immediate recognition, but it’s the chemistry between Kara Tointon and Allen Leech that makes the thriller work – or not, depending on your taste.

Frequently asked questions